[MSP] Search Equity
The method, published

The 100-point Search Equity scorecard.

The scorecard looks at five areas of how your MSP shows up online, using 23 checks and public data only. It's the same list in the free snapshot, the paid audit and every re-score, so you can read exactly how you'll be measured before you talk to anyone.

The scorecard page of a snapshot for the fictional MSP Example IT: each check, the points available and the points earned.
This is how the scorecard appears in a snapshot, here for a fictional MSP called Example IT.
The five areas

Where the hundred points go.

Reviews and AI visibility carry the most weight because they are what a buyer reads first, and each area below links to its checks.

Area 1 · 26 points

Reviews & referral sites

Reviews are the first thing a buyer reads and one of the strongest local signals Google uses. How recent they are matters as much as the star rating.

CheckPoints
20+ Google reviews per office5
Google rating 4.5 or higher5
New reviews in the last 90 days7
Owner replies to 80%+ of reviews4
Listed on 3+ referral and review sites5
Area 2 · 24 points

AI visibility

More buyers now ask an AI assistant for a shortlist before they search. If it doesn't name you, they may never get as far as checking you.

CheckPoints
Named when buyers ask AI for an IT company12
Website cited when named5
AI crawlers allowed in3
Answer-first content and FAQs4
Area 3 · 18 points

Web presence

This is whether your Google listings, your website and the business directories tell the same story, and whether a buyer can see the people who do the work.

CheckPoints
Google Business Profile claimed and complete, every office6
Name, address and phone identical on Google, site and directories5
Real office address in the target metro, shown on the site3
Named experts with credentials4
Area 4 · 18 points

SEO architecture

This is whether there's a page for what a buyer searches for, meaning the service, the city and the industry.

CheckPoints
A page for each core service5
Location pages for the cities they serve3
Industry pages3
Schema: LocalBusiness, Service, FAQ4
Sitemap and no index blockers3
Area 5 · 14 points

Website stack

This is whether your site loads quickly on a phone, can be read without running scripts, is secure, and can count the leads it brings in.

CheckPoints
Core Web Vitals pass on mobile4
Content is in the HTML (server-rendered)3
HTTPS and security headers3
Site kept up to date2
Call and form tracking2
What a score means

Four bands, from invisible to Search Equity.

0–39 InvisibleBuyers who look you up find very little, or they find a competitor first.
40–59 FindableYou show up, but your reviews, pages or AI answers lose the comparison with other providers.
60–79 CompetitiveYou hold your own, and a few specific gaps are costing you calls.
80–100 Search EquityBuyers find you, check you and see a provider worth calling.
AI visibility

Why AI visibility is a rate, not one answer.

An AI assistant can give a different answer every time you ask the same question, so a single answer is never your score. We ask the same buyer questions several times, on more than one assistant, and score the share of answers that name you.

That way, if you ask a question yourself and get a different answer, it doesn't contradict your score. The questions include "best managed IT provider in [city]", "IT support for a dental practice, law firm or manufacturer in [city]", "[your MSP] reviews", and questions about specific services such as backup, Microsoft 365, co-managed IT, compliance, AI readiness and an outsourced IT department.

If you'd like to see the scorecard run across a whole market, read the Utah index.

Score yourself on the five things that matter most

The one-minute search check asks five questions you can answer from memory, then shows you your weakest area and the fix I'd do first.